KitchenEquipment HQ
Browse equipment & guides
KitchenMatch ↗
← Back to the buying guide

THE EQUIPMENT EDIT / HEAD-TO-HEAD

Newair 44-lb Nugget Ice Maker vs Frigidaire EFIC255

Two machines rated up to 44 lb a day, but actual water, control and cleaning routines are what separate them.

Both advertise 44 lb/day; this is a production measure, not 44 pounds held at once. Compare bin/storage capacity, water refills, cleaning and exact retail variant.

OPTION 01
Newair NIM044BSN2 black nugget ice machine isolated on white background.

Newair
44 lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

US model: NIM044BSN2

Newair rates this countertop machine for up to 44 pounds of nugget ice a day. Its removable basket holds 2.7 pounds, so plan around the ice you need at one time.

Read full assessment →

Documented details

Daily production
44 lb (manufacturer rating)
Basket
2.7 lb
Footprint
9.5 W × 13.6 D × 14.9 H in
Manufacturer reference
OPTION 02
Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 44-lb nugget ice maker in navy blue, isolated on white.

Frigidaire Gallery
Gallery 44-lb Nugget Ice Maker (Navy)

US model: EFIC255 (Navy)

The Gallery EFIC255 family offers nugget ice with touch controls and a self-clean function. Its rated output is up to 44 pounds a day; the linked Amazon variant is Navy.

Read full assessment →

Documented details

Rated production
Up to 44 lb nugget ice per 24 h (manufacturer)
Controls
Touchscreen with self-clean function
Finish on Amazon
Navy (EFIC255 family)
Amazon ASIN
B0BCXJ5VQL
Manufacturer reference
About this comparison

This comparison draws on manufacturer specifications rather than our own hands-on tests. Follow the full reviews for more detail, including attributed independent perspectives where available. Check the selected Amazon model and current offer before buying.

PERSONALISED EQUIPMENT CHOICE

Which one makes sense in your kitchen?

Tell KitchenMatch what you want to make and how often. You’ll get a shortlist with the reasons to consider each model and the details to check.

Find my fit with KitchenMatch ↗